Cat Owner Discovers Hidden Wall Stash of Missing Toys

Share this story on Facebook!

Musician Uncovers Long-Lost Toy Stash in Unexpected Spot

For years, musician Lisa Chosed has devoted herself to keeping her cherished feline, Butter, happy and entertained. Like many doting pet parents, Chosed noticed her cat’s favorite playthings—small, colorful, mouse-shaped toys—and began buying them in bulk.

“These toys come like 60 in one box and don’t break the bank, especially over the years,” Chosed wrote in a social media post.

Colorful toy mice collected for Butter the cat

The Ongoing Toy Mystery

But a strange pattern began to emerge inside the home she shares with Butter. Despite continuously purchasing numerous toy mice, the majority of them kept disappearing without a trace.

Chosed occasionally managed to retrieve a few scattered under the couch, hidden in corners, or tucked away in closets, but the vast majority of them remained missing.

“I would find, like, a dozen in certain areas that I was now familiar with (under the couch, in a closet, etc.) but never to the extent that I was buying them,” she explained in an interview with The Dodo. “There was no place in my house, that I was aware of, where the toys could be that I hadn’t already looked in.”

A Basement Clue Unlocks the Mystery

The turning point came recently when Chosed noticed Butter playing on the stairway to the basement. Suddenly, the toy mouse she had been batting around vanished. Upon closer inspection, Chosed discovered a tiny crevice along the stairway wall—large enough for a small toy to slip through.

Driven by curiosity, she decided to investigate the hollow space beneath the stairs. What she found was nothing short of astonishing: a secret feline treasure trove.

Butter’s Secret Toy Stash Revealed

Underneath the stairwell lay Butter’s long-lost collection—dozens upon dozens of brightly colored toy mice that had quietly made their descent through the hidden crevice over the years.

“I just assumed some day I would find them,” Chosed shared. “I don’t know that I imagined they’d all be in one spot, though!”

In a follow-up video, Butter appears to be just as surprised as Chosed, gazing curiously at the uncovered collection as if to say, “So that’s where they went!”

Time to Pause the Shopping Cart

Some of the newest additions to the pile still looked clean and almost brand new, but many of the older mice had accumulated dust and grime. Even so, the discovery means that Chosed can postpone her next order of cat toys—for now.

“I had another box in my cart before I found this,” she confessed with a laugh.

The Charm of a Mischievous Cat

Though unknowingly hoarding dozens of toys beneath the stairs, Butter isn’t in trouble. For Chosed, the entire experience was just another endearing episode in her cat’s playful life.

“Butter most definitely makes daily life more interesting, even when she’s being naughty,” Chosed said. “She makes me laugh every day.”

Key Takeaways from the Tale of the Missing Mice

  • Lisa Chosed’s cat Butter had been unintentionally hoarding toy mice under the stairs.
  • A small crevice on a stairway wall allowed the toys to fall into a hidden space.
  • The discovery ended a long-standing mystery of disappearing toys.
  • Both owner and cat were amused and delighted by the reunion.

Butter’s playful antics have not only brought joy to her human but also reminded pet lovers everywhere of the delightful surprises our furry companions provide every day.

Share this story on Facebook!

Facebook Comments